The Power of Thank You: Reflecting on U-46 Experience

Photo by Vie Studio on Pexels.com

The words, “thank you”, may come across as trite to some people, especially if accompanied by contradictory actions. In my opinion, however, the words are not uttered nearly enough in spaces of education and even more so in educational leadership where central office leaders dwell. As a result of this void, I hope to break that pattern starting with myself and using this opportunity to say, “Thank you” to several individuals who I may not have said, “thank you” enough to. Please bear with me as I use the beginning to lay some context.

My last day in School District U-46 was Monday, June 3rd; I thought I had at least another two hours to pen a thank you email to my immediate supervisor, district superintendent, and other colleagues, but I was mistaken. Precisely at 3:00pm, my emails were shut off, I was booted out of the district system, and just like that I was done. Although a quick thank you text message to a few of my colleagues was composed and sent, I was still uneasy about leaving without a proper thank you message. Text messages, in my opinion, can often lack the emotion one wishes to convey. In hindsight, so can face-to-face conversations. Sure, I could have called and extended a more personable thank you, but I needed to put my thoughts in writing. This latest blog, I hope, captures my deepest appreciation in a way that I was unable to share just one month prior. 

As a former health and physical education teacher, there were several units I enjoyed teaching more than others. One unit in particular that stuck with me was about the dimensions of wellness; yes, even 25+ years ago, we were teaching about physical, emotional, social, and mental well-being. In retrospect, SEL is not new. Rather, SEL has been repackaged and repurposed, possibly with a bit more fervor as trauma appears to manifest itself daily in the lives of both adults and children. While lesson planning many moons ago, I learned that when you value something or someone you should publicly and privately affirm it/them. During the daily grind over the past four years, I am not sure I did just that. So, as previously stated, I hope to convey my deepest appreciation for my colleagues, inclusive of the experiences afforded me during my tenure in School District U-46. 

Four years ago, I joined the U-46 team as the Assistant Superintendent of Equity and Innovation. Unlike most school districts, U-46 had a position devoted to equity before diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) efforts were a thing and more recently, under attack. Unfortunately, my predecessor, the late Mr. Ron Raglin, passed away unexpectedly during the late summer of 2019. Consequently,  his position remained vacant for quite some time. After undergoing a rigorous interview process (I count at least three trips to Elgin for interviews), I was hired. It was an honor for me to follow Mr. Raglin, a man who gave his all in advancing equity. Although we never met, Mr. Raglin’s legacy continues to be on display in U-46. For full disclosure, I figured I could handle the “equity” portion of the job, but the “innovation” involved a myriad of duties that I would learn by doing while also leaning on very competent colleagues. I was eager and ready to get to work, but I started my new role right during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic. What I remember vividly about my start was the kindness extolled to me by my then-supervisor, Deputy Superintendent Dr. Suzanne Johnson.

I am proud to say that Dr. Johnson is now serving as the district’s superintendent, a position she earned and I contend, she unequivocally deserved having started her career at U-46 more than 27 years ago. Dr. Johnson as well as my colleague and eventually new boss, Ms. Lela Majstorovic, were what Shane Safir would describe as listening leaders. One of several attributes of a Listening Leader, according to Ms. Safir, is that they “construct a vision through a collaborative process in which dialogue and dissenting perspectives are welcome” (2017, p.5). Although we did not agree on every decision made, Superintendent Johnson and Deputy Superintendent Majstorovic were open to my ideas and more importantly, gave me the space to ask questions without fear of backlash. When my mother transitioned in the winter of 2022, Dr. Johnson was present at my mom’s homegoing and her willingness to share her own experiences of living with grief helped me better understand that grief is merely symbolic of love. When, after working alongside and underneath Superintendent Johnson and Deputy Superintendent Majstorovic since 2020, I opted to spread my wings once more, they both supported my endeavor and I am truly grateful for you both! 

I also want to thank Melissa Stevenson. Melissa was my administrative assistant upon my hire at U-46, but she was more than that. When I had this lofty idea of U-46 launching an inaugural equity symposium, more often than not, Melissa had to put on her investigative hat and find the individuals whom I believed should be a part of our launch and subsequent symposium.  Individuals who would eventually serve as our keynote speakers and/or lead breakout sessions included incredible human beings such as Drs. Gloria Ladson-Billings, Geneva Gay, Beverly Daniel Tatum, Gholdy Muhammad, Bettina Love, Yolanda Sealey Ruiz, Chris Emdin, Dena Simmons, Pedro Noguera, Ian Mette, Don Parker, Jahkari ‘JT’ Taylor, and countless others. I was barely holding my nose above water and with just a vision over lunch in my office, the equity symposium was birthed. It was probably my constant fervor to birth this baby (Equity Symposium), twice, that led Melissa to an early retirement 😊. I am grateful for her friendship to this day. My department colleagues, Mitch Briesemeister, Michele Chapman, Alexa Charsa-Hahn, Elizabeth McKinney, Doreen Roberts, Tiffany Mikhail Wright, and Roz Cobbs. Whether we were together from my arrival to one year ago, I am thankful for them for their camaraderie, collegiality, sheer professionalism, and their willingness to engage around our monthly topic, “How does our work connect to equity?”

I would be remiss if I did not acknowledge the 70+ U-46 Equity Committee Ambassador Leaders and members whose dedication helped transform U-46 Equity Plan 1.0 to a more robust and comprehensive rendition referred to as Equity Plan 2.0. Where would I be without their relentless commitment to engaging in this work with me? Without monetary compensation, they showed up to most meetings and stayed the course even when the course seemed ridiculously long. There are way too many names to list and I will inadvertently forget at least two people if I traverse down that road. Please know that my heart remains full because of you!

I also want to extend a special thank you to Illinois State Superintendent, Tony Sanders. Dr. Sanders took a chance on me four years ago as he brought me into his tightly-knit circle of Cabinet colleagues. Moreover, early on in my tenure at U-46, Dr. Sanders allowed me to bend his ear as I watched in awe his adeptness at navigating politically charged waters. 

As I prepare to close, I will admit that I asked my boss to not make a big deal of my leaving the district. I wanted no fanfare, no farewell luncheon, no hugs or tears, just a quiet exit down Chicago Street in Elgin, Illinois to my parked car. She reluctantly obliged. Although there was no farewell luncheon, my dearest friend, Lisa Jackson, who also doubled as our Director of Equity and Inclusion, managed to secretly arrange a farewell dinner during our district’s final equity committee meeting of the school year. This farewell gathering resulted in more tears than I wanted to shed. There is indeed a gentle side of me; more gentle than most know. Needless to say, my tears coupled with a plethora of warm embraces will serve as a reminder of the positive relationships established during my time in U-46. When I consider Lisa’s influence in our short time together, I am drawn to a book, The Power of Moments, gifted to Cabinet members by Superintendent Johnson. The authors, Chip and Dan Heath write about the importance of recognizing others. In particular, the authors write, “Expressing gratitude pleases the recipient of the praise, of course, but it can also have a boomerang effect, elevating the spirits of the grateful person” (2017, p. 155). Lisa’s spirits always seemed to be on high; she rarely, if ever, seemed frazzled and took the time to acknowledge every single person she encountered. She remembered small moments and some of the most important milestones in my life like the heavenly anniversary of my mother. Lisa is the epitome of gracefulness and if you ever get to meet her, you will undoubtedly agree. Lisa, thank you, for being an audacious listener and trusted confidant. You gave me the liberty to push and pull while I grew alongside you. From you, I learned to be more graceful in my approach, and to not be the one to speak first or last; instead, I learned to be present. I am convinced your spirits were always on high because you continuously expressed gratitude toward others. You are a gift to me and so many others!

Finally, the importance of pausing to recognize others is inarguably one of the most powerful opportunities to galvanize community and trust, yet it must be done with authenticity and specificity. The Heath brothers reminded me that “while recognition is a universal expectation, it’s not a universal practice” (p.146). I want to be better and do better because the power of a thank you is just as important for the giver as it is for the receiver. U-46, thank you for bringing me on the team, allowing me to learn and grow, and when the time was right, to fly! Godspeed!

-T

References

Heath, C., & Heath, D. (2017). The power of moments: why certain experiences have extraordinary impact.
Safir, S. (2017). The listening leader: Creating the conditions for equitable school transformation. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Your Silence Will Not Save You!

Within the educational sphere, July and August tend to mark the beginnings of fresh leadership appointments in both school and central office positions. As fresh faces assume a new leadership role, many are afforded the opportunity to build their own leadership team. In prior years, I was blessed to have an opportunity to sit on new leadership teams, both at the school level and on a Superintendent’s cabinet. In each of those leadership appointments, I walked into the role with some hesitancy about my abilities and how I would share my ideas, opinions, and sometimes reservations about a particular idea initiated by my boss. Perhaps it was imposter syndrome that led me to lead and question with trepidation. Too often I questioned my preparedness for certain roles. Unfortunately, it is not uncommon for some women, especially women of Color, to internalize feelings of inadequacy. Academic and author, Julia Chang, recounts her experiences in academia while in a tenured track position at an Ivy League University. Chang stated, “The imposter syndrome causes me to feel precisely this: that I am not one with my skin, as though I had the encasing of one fruit and the flesh of another” (2020, p. 261). Chang described my sentiments precisely. I entered the workplace as a confident Black woman having started my career in Baltimore City Public Schools in the early 1990s, but I would find that my Blackness was too much for others to bear in other spaces. As a result, I tempered a little of myself to belong and get along.

While I began my 28th year in education earlier this month, I must remind myself that I have served as a teacher, assistant principal, principal, assistant superintendent, and superintendent at various points in my career. I pursued the superintendency at the encouragement of a former boss current Superintendent and friend, Dr. Andre D. Spencer. Even with a wealth of experience in various school systems, my inner being was always on guard for self-doubt to seep in. Still, I was pleasantly surprised that on many occasions, my immediate supervisors assured me, through their interactions, affirmations, delegated responsibilities, and a keen interest in my continued growth, that I was hired because they unequivocally believed in me.My input was welcomed, if not sought after, by a handful of supervisors. I recall times when they would never allow a meeting to conclude without the voices of those at the table being heard. In the beginning, I shunned this practice. I was weary of being called on in front of others for fear of saying the wrong thing or simply not knowing what to say. Yet, the spaces these leaders created allowed for conversations to ensue without fear of embarrassment or judgment. Later in my career, I would do my best to embody that same practice of seeking the thoughts and ideas of others. As a former school leader and cabinet official charged with leading, it was rare for me to conclude a meeting without everyone’s voice being heard. For example, prior to moving forward with any systems’ level change, I would pose a very simple question to my direct reports and/or colleagues that asked, “What are the landmines?” Landmines may not have been the best word choice, but the phrase conveyed, “consequential impact”. As I observed the plethora of new leadership appointments shared in the local media and/or on social media platforms this summer, I thought to myself, who will ask, “What are the landmines?” Who will challenge ideas that are not fully fleshed out or simply flawed?

Well, there is no need for me to withhold my thoughts from you any longer. In considering the political and vitriol atmosphere plaguing schools, school board meetings, and other venues where school personnel gather, I rely on the good book, the Bible, to share my lingering thoughts. Specifically, I am drawn to the book of Esther as I try to frame my thinking around leadership. In my opinion, the Book of Esther is one chunk full of the essential elements for making a great story. There is the protagonist and antagonist, exhilarating suspense, conflict, and finally, a resolution. For those who are unfamiliar with the Book of Esther, I will provide a brief synopsis and hope that this summary, albeit brief, compels you to dust off your bible, find Esther, and get to reading. Esther, raised by her uncle Mordecai, is a Jewish woman from the Persian diaspora. King Ahasuerus, at the first sighting of Esther, becomes enamored with her beauty. Long story short, King Ahasuerus makes Esther his wife. According to some bible scholars, in the time leading up to the King and Esther’s wedding and during the early part of their marriage, Esther did not reveal her Jewish heritage to her husband, the King. Mordecai made this request of Esther for fear that the King would abandon all thoughts of marriage to Esther. If you’re wondering why, well now is a good time to go get that bible. There is another character in the Book of Esther, Haman. Haman, an advisor to King Ahasuerus, is promoted above all the king’s officials and the king demands that everyone bow down to Haman. Mordecai refused to kneel and bow down. This refusal, in an act of defiance, is where things get interesting and where I draw parallels between the book of Esther and present-day leadership.

As I shared in my opening, the summer months typically mark the beginning of fresh starts for school and central office leaders. School principals and superintendents are sometimes able to appoint new leadership to their inner circle whether as an assistant principal in schools or chief of staff, assistant superintendent, or similar positions at the Cabinet level. If you are new to your position, you may not feel as inclined nor encouraged to voice your thoughts and opinions especially when they may be in opposition to the views of your supervisor and/or colleagues. If, however, you were selected to serve in a leadership position, then it is critically important that you muster the courage to speak up and out. I recognize, however, that sharing your thoughts and ideas is easier said than done especially when speaking, uninvited, can come with consequences-some immediate and tangible, while others slow and career hazardous. But bell hooks (2004) reminded us on many occasions that our voice is not just a matter of self-preservation, but our voice can serve as a movement to trample the systems of oppression. So, why stay quiet? For whose comfort are we considering? Who is harmed by our silence?

When Mordecai refused to show deference to Haman, Haman was enraged. Haman’s anger further fueled his hatred of people of Jewish descent and led him to devise a plot to destroy all Jews. Mordecai learned of Haman’s plot and went to Esther with a plea that she intercede on behalf of her people to the king. Esther is hesitant to go to the king because, according to the customs and laws during that time, she is keenly aware that approaching the king without him beckoning for her can lead to her death. Mordecai learns of Esther’s hesitancy and sends a powerful message back to Esther, “Do not think that because you are in the king’s house that you alone of all the Jews will escape. For if you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance for the Jews will arise from another place, but you and your father’s family will perish. And who knows but that you have come to your royal position for such a time as this?” (New International Version, 2011, Esther 4:13-14)

When scouring the internet and electronic library databases using keywords like, “Mordecai”, “Esther”, “courage”, and “leadership”, the findings seem to depict Esther as the heroine. I, however, want to offer a different perspective, one that illuminates the courage of Mordecai. Look at Mordecai’s position; he is not the king nor is he the king’s official. Yet, Mordecai uses his ‘given’ position as a means of influence and thus, I draw parallels to your position and mine. There are at least three types of organizational power: role power, relationship power, and expertise power. Of the three types of power, relationship power is often underestimated. Relationship power is our ability to forge relationships with others regardless of where one falls on an organizational chart. Even John Maxwell affirms this position in his book, The 360 Degree Leader. Specifically, Maxwell posits, “You can lead others from anywhere in an organization” (2011, p.7). While Mordecai had a relationship with his niece, he could have remained quiet, but he did not. Mordecai used his relationship and positionality to wield some influence over the “role” power his niece held.

After Esther, Mordecai, and their people engaged in three days of fasting and praying, Esther was petitioned by the king who wanted to know why she was in such distress. Esther shared with the king the plot Haman devised to annihilate the Jewish people. In the end, Haman was impaled on the pole that he had set up for Mordecai. The book of Esther has ten chapters, so many details are withheld here. The moral of this story is to illustrate the power of one voice, a voice that refused to be silenced. If you believe the parallels I am attempting to make between Mordecai, Esther, and those of us in leadership positions are hyperbolic, then do nothing. But, if you visualize the faces of individual students, countless families, and even staff members who are harmed by our unwillingness and/or fear of speaking up, then I implore you to be silent no more.

The journey of leadership is often a complex and nuanced one, shaped by our personal experiences, societal dynamics, and the courage to overcome self-doubt. As we navigate the educational arena, marked by transitions and fresh beginnings in leadership positions, it is imperative to reflect upon the lessons from history that can guide us in these roles. The parallels drawn from the Book of Esther, I hope, offer profound insights into the essence of leadership. Esther’s courage to step forward despite the risks she faced resonates with the challenges many leaders encounter when speaking out against the status quo. Likewise, Mordecai’s courage and unwavering determination to make his voice heard, even from a position of relative powerlessness, underscores the influence that relationships and the willingness to speak up can wield in effecting change. Leadership should not be confined to titles or positions, but rather should emerge from the disposition to inspire and influence others, regardless of where one sits on the organizational hierarchy. The power of relationship, expertise, and the willingness to challenge flawed ideas or systems can shape the course of leadership trajectories, ultimately contributing to the transformation of educational institutions and beyond.

Finally, let us draw courage from the stories of those who dared to speak up, who challenged the norm, and who used their positions of influence to create something beautiful for those we’ve been charged to serve. In doing so, we can pave the way for a more inclusive, thoughtful, and impactful educational sphere that empowers leaders to rise above self-doubt and champion positive transformation. As we step into new leadership roles or continue to grow in our current ones, let us heed the wisdom of author and activist, Audre Lorde who said, “It is learning how to stand alone, unpopular and sometimes reviled, and how to make common cause with those others identified as outside the structures in order to define and seek a world in which we can all flourish” (2017, p. 91).                       

References

Change, J. H. (2020). Spectacular Bodies. In Y. F. Niemann G. G. yMuhs & C. G. Gonzalez (Eds.), Presumed Incompetent II-Race, Class, Power, and Resistance of Women in Academia. Utah State University Press.

hooks, b. (2004). Rock my Soul-Black People and Self-Esteem. Simon & Schuster.

Lorde, A. (2017). Your Silence Will Not Protect You. Silver Press.

Maxwell, John C. (2005). The 360-degree leader: developing your influence from anywhere in the organization. California: Nelson Business.

New International Version. (2011). BibleGateway.com http://biblegateway.com/versons/ New- International–Version-NIV